Why Guests Get Lost in Your Venue and What to Fix First

Kevin Lynch asked people to draw their city from memory. He found five things they all used. This essay reads those five things as a venue. It shows why guests get lost and what to fix first. It gives you rules for a hall that is easy to picture, and a sketch map test to run with your own guests.
"Where is Hall 4?" By lunch on day one, the people at the info desk are tired of that question. Most planners blame the signs. Kevin Lynch would have blamed the plan.
Guests get lost in venues for the same reason people get lost in cities. The place gives them nothing clear to hold in their heads. In The Image of the City (1960), Lynch named five things people use to picture a place. Read as a venue, they explain the empty back hall and the queue at the info desk. They also show what to fix first.
Lost in the hall
The failures are familiar. There is the back hall nobody finds. There is the queue at the info desk asking the same three questions. And there is the guest who cannot find the way out when the doors close.
Each one is usually blamed on the signs. Most are failures of the plan first. Signs can name what a space already makes clear. They cannot save a space that makes nothing clear.
What did Kevin Lynch find?
Lynch's book was published by MIT Press in 1960. It reported a five year study of Boston, Jersey City and Los Angeles. People who lived there were asked to draw maps of their city from memory. Boston gave people a strong, shared picture. Jersey City gave them far less to hold.
Lynch gave this quality a name, imageability. It means how easily a place forms a clear picture that sticks in your mind. The book is usually credited as the first to use the word wayfinding, which means finding your way. Paul Arthur and Romedi Passini later took the idea into signs and buildings, in their 1992 book Wayfinding.
Lynch studied cities, not venues. Yet his tools carry over. That is a small case for the wide reading urged in Why Designers Can't Think.
Five things guests use to picture a venue
Lynch found five elements that come up again and again in the maps people keep in their heads. Each one has a venue version and a way it often fails.
Paths are the lines people move along. In a venue they are aisles, corridors and wide halls. They fail when they come to a dead end, bend without warning or melt into a grid of aisles that all look the same.
Edges are lines between places that people do not walk along. In a venue they are hall walls, the line between the stands and the food, or a glass front. They fail when you cannot see them, so people cannot tell they have left a zone. They also fail when they block without warning, so people walk up to a wall with no door.
Districts are areas with a look you can recognize. In a venue they are country pavilions, product sectors or a quiet area. They fail when every zone looks alike and a guest cannot tell one hall from the next.
Nodes are points where people enter, where routes meet and where choices happen. In a venue they are junctions, registration, the food court and the front of the main stage. They fail when a junction gives no view of the choices and nothing says which way is which.
Landmarks are things you can see from far away and steer by. In a venue they are a hanging sign, a tall stand or a feature you can see across the hall. They fail when there are none. They also fail when there are so many that none stands out.
A big site that is easy to read
Expo 2020 Dubai shows the five elements on a big site. HOK led the master plan, with Populous and Arup. Three themed districts spread out from a central plaza called Al Wasl. They are Opportunity, Mobility and Sustainability. Al Wasl is the old Arab name for Dubai, and it means the connection. Shaded walkways link the districts.
Al Wasl works as a node and a landmark at once. Each district gives visitors a look to place themselves by. The same plan fits a single hall. Make one central node with a landmark. Make two or three districts, each with its own look. Make every path lead back to the center. Space planning for trade shows sets the aisles and main features that carry it.
Fix the space first, then the signs
The order of work matters. First make the five elements clear in the plan. Then add signs that name them.
Signs that agree with what the space already says are read at a glance. Signs that must do all the work draw a crowd standing under them, reading. For the sign system itself, Otl Aicher's Munich 1972 design is the model.
A few rules of thumb follow.
- One landmark per hall, seen from each of its entrances.
- A change of color or floor at every district edge.
- A node at every big choice point, with a view of the choices.
- Paths that end at a node, never at a blank wall.
- Step free paths drawn in from the start, because finding your way is part of access.
Ask guests to draw your venue
Lynch's method works in any venue. Here is how to run it.
- Pick the moment. Run it after a walk through of the plan, or with guests at the end of the event.
- Ask five to ten guests to draw the venue from memory. Give each one the same words. "Draw this venue as if you were explaining it to a friend who arrives tomorrow. Put in anything that helped you find your way."
- Count the elements on each map.
- Read the gaps. Whatever shows up rarely is not clear.
- Fix it and test again.
| Element | Name in your plan | Maps that show it | Fix if it shows up rarely |
|---|---|---|---|
| Path | Main hall walk | of 10 | Make it straight and wide, or end it at a node |
| Edge | Hall wall, food line | of 10 | Change the floor or color at the line |
| District | Each sector or zone | of 10 | Give it its own color, floor or ceiling |
| Node | Registration, main junction | of 10 | Open the view of the choices |
| Landmark | Central hanging feature | of 10 | Raise it, light it and remove what competes with it |
Test it the way Lynch tested Boston
Go back to the info desk and the question about Hall 4. Ask ten guests to draw your venue. If Hall 4 is missing from most maps, no sign will save it. Give it a landmark, a path that leads there and a look of its own. Then the info desk will get better questions.
Lynch's five elements must be clear in the plan before any sign goes up. Monet lays out your venue to scale from its plan and a brief. Renders and walkthrough videos then let your team judge the paths, nodes and landmarks before guests arrive. Get started for free on Monet.