The Aesthetic Vacuum

Themed events lift the look of past eras and leave the meaning behind. This essay uses Tibor Kalman, J. Abbott Miller and Karrie Jacobs on good history and bad history to fix that. You get a then and now sheet for any theme. You also get a four part test that tells a nod to the past from a knockoff.
You open an invitation with gold edges. The theme is the Roaring Twenties. Wear feathers. There will be a jazz band and a tower of champagne glasses. Nobody says why the host chose the 1920s, or what the 1920s were like.
In 1991 Tibor Kalman, J. Abbott Miller and Karrie Jacobs wrote an essay about this mistake. It was called "Good History/Bad History". One line in it gives this essay its title. "To look at artifacts without knowing what they were in their own time is to look into a vacuum". Themed events do this every season. They lift the look of the Jazz Age, Art Deco or 1970s disco. They leave behind everything those styles were saying.
What is good history and bad history?
The essay ran in the March/April 1991 issue of Print. It came back in Looking Closer in 1994 (text). It is often put down to Kalman alone, but all three wrote it.
Their main claim is plain. Bad design history takes a style out of its time. Then the style becomes "a detachable attribute, a veneer rather than an expression of content". A veneer is a thin skin glued on top. And designers abuse history, they wrote, "when they use it as a shortcut". It becomes a quick route to looking serious, and to sales.
Jive modernism and the lounge act
The authors had words for the problem. "Jive modernism" was their name for a revival that treats modernism as dead. It sees it as an old look, not a living belief. Their verdict was blunt. "Modernism without the spirit is Trump Tower".
Bad history, they wrote, is like a lounge musician who plays the hits note for note. You learn nothing about the music. But they were not against borrowing. In their words, there is "an important difference between making an allusion and doing a knockoff". An allusion is a nod to the past that adds something new. A knockoff just copies. The gap between them is change.
The theme rack
Each season brings the same list. There are the Roaring Twenties, Art Deco, Old Hollywood and the 1960s office. There is Studio 54 disco, a Venetian masked ball, even "Bauhaus". Each one arrives as a mood board, a décor hire catalog and a dress code.
The look travels, and the meaning does not. A theme chosen this way tells guests the host had a budget, not a point. Feather boas and gold fans arrive at the gala. They come without a word about what the 1920s were like, or why the host chose them.
The Gatsby problem
F. Scott Fitzgerald published The Great Gatsby in 1925. Its parties are shows among strangers. Its host is dead by the end. The book is about how empty that wealth is. Baz Luhrmann's film of 2013 gave the theme a fresh set of pictures.
Now apply the authors' method. In the book, a Gatsby party meant excess, loneliness and money from who knows where. At a firm's gala now, it means glamour and fun. That is close to the reverse. Irony can be on purpose, and then it can be good. Irony by accident is the vacuum.
Then and now, for any theme
The essay's own worked example is a Ralph Lauren box. It shows a golfer in 1920s clothes with a propeller plane overhead. The authors read it as if it was made in 1927. Then they read it as if it was made in 1987. The plane meant "progress" in the first year and "quaintness" in the second.
The same questions make a then and now sheet for any theme. Ask them of each key picture, prop or style choice. Answer each question twice, once for then and once for now.
- What did this image mean to its audience?
- Who took part, and who was left out?
- Did the style say new, or old fashioned?
- What was thought dull or bad at the time?
- What can we not understand, because we were not part of that culture?
- What has become invisible to people today?
- Who made it, and for whom?
Five of these adapt the closing questions that, in the authors' view, good history asks. The rest come from their Ralph Lauren example. A theme with no answers for then is a costume.
Good history in a room
A theme with a text behind it looks different. The Met's 2019 Costume Institute show was about camp, a love of the showy and the overdone. It took Susan Sontag's 1964 essay "Notes on Camp" as its frame. It also gave that year's gala, on May 6, 2019, its theme (The Met). It traced how camp moved from the edges into the mainstream, with Sontag's essay as its spine. The theme had an argument, and the argument came first.
The authors' lesson from Constructivism, a bold Russian art style from the early 1900s, points the same way. Learn its freedom with word order and its loose ranking of parts. Do not copy its type set at 45 degrees. Here is a task for your next brief. Art Deco loved new stuff, speed and the machine. Design a room that loves today's new stuff in the same spirit, without a single sunburst.
Sometimes a theme should give way to feeling instead of reference. Form follows function vs. form follows emotion covers that case. The nostalgia trap covers the brand version of the same mistake.
Allusion or knockoff?
Use a four part test. A reference passes only if your team can state four things.
- What it meant then.
- What it means now.
- Which strategy it borrows, not which style trick.
- What the event says through it.
Fail any one and it is a knockoff. Pass all four and it has earned its place on the mood board. That holds for a pop up or a brand activation as much as for a gala.
A spark, not a costume rack
The authors closed on the difference. Bad design history says "here, this is nice, use it". Good design history says "this is how designers thought about their work then... Now, what can you do?"
Go back to the invitation with gold edges. Can the host say what the 1920s meant, what they mean now and what the party says through them? Then keep the feathers. If not, the room is a vacuum with a dress code.
Frequently asked questions
What is Good History/Bad History?
It is a 1991 essay in Print by Tibor Kalman, J. Abbott Miller and Karrie Jacobs. It argues that lifting a style out of its time turns it into a thin veneer. Good history asks what a style meant then and what it can do now.
Why do themed events often fall flat?
They borrow the look of an era and leave its meaning behind. Guests get feathers and gold fans with no idea why the host chose the 1920s. The theme says the host had a budget, not a point.
How do you tell an allusion from a knockoff?
State four things. Say what the reference meant then and what it means now. Say which strategy it borrows, not which style. Then say what your event says through it. Fail any one and it is a knockoff.
Monet's moodboards let you test a theme against your idea before you hire any décor. Its renders show the room to scale in your venue. So you can see if the theme says something before the guests arrive. Get started for free on Monet.